Blog Post

The 1,000 Billion Dollar Return Problem.

Lawrence Lerner • Jan 10, 2024

AI has a strong ROI as long as Retailers play to its strengths

It’s not a typo. I wrote a trillion dollars that way because it’s such an unrelatable amount, and it’s hard to fathom what it’s like to manage.


That’s the number in returns cost retailers are facing. The National Retail Federation reported shoppers returned 16.5% percent of the goods purchased, double that of 2019. There is such a thing as reducing the friction of ordering.


Between Covid and the ease of online ordering, consumers have adopted behaviors similar to a dressing room in a clothing store. 


They pick out an assortment of items, knowing that retailers are making it easier to return, with some stores acting as a destination point. In many instances, consumers must only return the item with its packaging. The number will grow as omnichannel (integrating multiple channels around the customer) programs become more widespread. 


Rethinking Returns: When Bricks-and-Mortar Becomes an Advantage


The article on Amazon's AI-powered "Fit Insights Tool" highlights a crucial challenge plaguing the retail industry: returns. As algorithms understand fits and consumer preferences, there are opportunities.


While I am a big fan of using technology as a tool to make life easier, I have doubts about AI fittings. Every company I buy from has a different fit; I’m “about” a large in most shirts and 16.5 neck for dress shirts. However, sizes vary, and in the past, when I shopped in Europe, the sizes went widely from American ones. 


The most extreme example occurred while shopping with my girlfriend for her next little black dress. The large one needed to be more significant. The small one of another brand was too big. Today, she orders three sizes online and returns the ones that don’t fit. I don’t see that problem being solved with an over-the-camera fitting.


More on AI in a bit. What if the solution lies in online algorithms and physical stores as a point of destination? Let's explore "returns advantage."


Sunk Costs, Smart Gains: Large retailers already own their store infrastructure, a sunk cost for online-only competitors. Physical locations have a built-in advantage as a point of destination. Returned items can be processed locally and potentially engage other partners for shipping, repairs, or cleaning. Ecosystems become platforms for returns.


If it sounds like a lot of effort, consider we started with a trillion-dollar target to reduce shipping costs and speed up restocking. Imagine a customer dropping off a pair of ill-fitting jeans at the nearest store, with the item immediately scanned and ready for resale.

Locker Up the Returns: While I was at Avanti, we designed and delivered an open award-winning locker ecosystem. Beyond delivery, strategically placed locker platforms offer another convenient option. Imagine shoppers returning items near their homes or workplaces, avoiding store visits altogether. 


This improves customer experience and frees up valuable sales floor space. Retailers can partner with existing locker networks, strengthening their physical presence and brand engagement.


Digital Wallets to the rescue: Immediate Credit, Instant Satisfaction: Immediate store credit via a digital wallet is a game-changer. Imagine returning those jeans and instantly having store credit plus another incentive in your preferred wallet, ready to be used on a new purchase – all within the same store visit. 


This not only incentivizes immediate re-spending but also strengthens wallet loyalty. Add a bonus for same-day purchases, and you have a recipe for increased customer satisfaction and brand affinity.


AI: The Fit Fixer and Beyond: While brick-and-mortar stores offer logistical advantages, AI can be the ultimate return management tool. 


AI is the opportunity to create a predictable and consistent advantage in analyzing return data to identify problematic inventory categories or sizing inconsistencies, guiding future purchasing decisions. AI can bring a lot of insight. Which products are most often returned (or least purchased), in which locations, and by which demographics? AI can empower employees closest to the customer in a way… “hitherto undreamt of.”  


So, what is next?

Recap

This dense and complex topic requires analysis and discussion before implementation.


  • Retailers face a trillion-dollar challenge with a significant increase in product returns, reaching 16.5% of purchased goods, double that of 2019. This rise is attributed to consumer behaviors mirroring dressing room practices facilitated by easy online ordering and return processes.
  • It’s critical not to implement solutions just for the novelty of having them. AI has a strong ROI as long as Retailers play to its strengths.
  • Concerns are raised about the efficacy of AI tools like Amazon's "Fit Insights Tool" in addressing the sizing and fit issues in online shopping. The inconsistency in sizes across different brands and regions makes AI fittings questionable, as consumers often order multiple sizes and return the ones that don't fit.
  • Solutions to the return problem involve leveraging physical store infrastructures for processing returns, introducing locker ecosystems for convenient drop-offs, offering instant store credit through digital wallets to encourage immediate re-spending, and utilizing AI to analyze return data for improving inventory management and sizing accuracy.


In the end, it is building a solution fit to purpose.


What do you think? What are the “gentle easing” opportunities you would envision for AI in return management? What return management initiatives are in your planning? What would you do or like to see next?

ABOUT THE AUTHOR


Lawrence


I translate the CEO, Owner, or Board vision and goals into market-making products that generate $100M in new revenue by expanding into geographies, industries, and verticals while adding customers.


As their trusted advisor, leaders engage me to crush their goals and grow, fix, or transition their businesses with a cumulative impact of $1B


👉🏼 Subscribe to Retail industry news, unpacking trends, and timely issues for leaders.

 

Ready to grow, address change, or transition your business? 👉🏼  Let's brainstorm

Share by: